BUTLER HOUSE at The Cherry Creek Inn

This 1860s Italian-inspired villa sits on 31.5 acres and is 1.5 miles from Cherry Creek in Amish country. Buffalo is 51 miles away. The 3 rooms and 1 suite are individually-decorated and furnished in an elegant traditional style. All rooms are non-smoking and have private bathrooms, while the 2-bedroom suite includes satellite TV and a separate sitting room. WiFi is available. A hearty breakfast is included and English afternoon teas are regularly served. There's a tower room with board games, an exercise room, a pavilion with hot tub and a conservatory. Amish-themed tours can be arranged at the hotel.